2024 Best of Maine

The Winners of Down East’s 2024 Best of Maine Poll

Our 17th annual roundup of Maine’s best everything, from taprooms to bookshops, lobster rolls to toy stores. How did your favorites do?

Down East readers first voted in a write-in round. The top-five vote getters in each category became finalists (give or take, in the event of ties). Then, readers picked winners in a multiple-choice final round. Here and there, we’ve spotlighted some notable winners and finalists, businesses both new and old, in retail, food, hospitality, and more.

News Keepsake is the only authorized plaque and reprint partner of Down East magazine

HOME & GARDEN

ARCHITECT

Knickerbocker Group
Boothbay, Portland

FINALISTS

Hay Runner
Portland, Rockport

Maple Street Design Studio
Camden

Phelps Architects
Damariscotta

North Sky Seven Architects
Blue Hill

BUILDER

Knickerbocker Group
Boothbay, Portland

FINALISTS

Marden Builders
Boothbay Harbor

O’Shea Builders
Waterford

BH Builders Inc.
Farmingdale

M.R. Brewer
Portland

HOME-IMPROVEMENT STORE

Hammond Lumber Company
Various locations

FINALISTS

Damariscotta Hardware
Damariscotta

Grover’s Hardware
Boothbay Harbor

E.L. Spear
Rockland

Rankin’s Hardware & Building Supplies
Camden

the showroom inside Davis Bros Furniture in Guilford, Maine

Head upta Davis Bros to outfit the camp. Photo by Dave Waddell

SPOTLIGHT

Camps all over the state are full of fittingly rustic furniture: armchairs upholstered in patterns with bears and pine cones and moose, rough-hewn wooden bed frames with a crisscross of bent boughs for headboards, lamps made from antlers, dining tables with skinny tree trunks for legs. That aesthetic isn’t what you find at most furniture stores, but it’s the prevailing look in the showrooms at Davis Bros, in Guilford, right in the heart of camp country. Our readers rightly count it among the best shops around. It could certainly stake a claim as the Maine-iest.

FURNITURE STORE

Dow Furniture
Waldoboro

FINALISTS

J.Plum Home
Lisbon Falls

Sproul’s Furniture
Newcastle

Sweet Dreams Home Furnishings
Brunswick

Davis Bros Furniture
Guildford

DÉCOR SHOP

GooeyGump Designs
Portland

FINALISTS

J.Plum Home
Lisbon Falls

Pistil & Page
Gardiner

The Rusticators Emporium
Hallowell

COVE by Knickerbocker Group
Boothbay

GARDEN CENTER/NURSERY

Longfellow’s Greenhouses
Manchester

FINALISTS

Moose Crossing Garden Center
Waldoboro

Skillins Greenhouses
Brunswick, Cumberland, Falmouth

Estabrook’s
Kennebunk, Yarmouth

Plants Unlimited
Rockport, Trenton

SHOPPING & STYLE

TOY STORE

Island Treasure Toys
Various locations

FINALISTS

Out on a Whimsey Toys
Belfast

Treehouse Toys
Biddeford, Portland

Planet Toys
Camden

Kennebunk Toy Company
Kennebunk

WOMEN’S BOUTIQUE

The Grasshopper Shop
Rockland

FINALISTS

Women Of Substance
Damariscotta

Coyote Moon
Belfast

Daisy Jane’s / Daisy Trading Co.
York

Beal House
Damariscotta

SPOTLIGHT

Businesses get voted into multiple categories often enough, but considering that J.Plum Home only found a permanent storefront last fall, its Best of Maine debut in no less than four categories — gift shops, antiques/vintage stores, décor shops, and furniture stores — makes for a pretty impressive feat. Back in 2021, husband- wife duo Josh Newton and Jenny Madden started driving around New England to purchase classic old furniture that they could restore and then sell at other shops. Last summer, they gave the brick-and- mortar model a trial run with a pop-up in Sebago, before moving into their current Lisbon Falls location. Coming in as a finalist in four categories is a credit to the shop’s mix of quality and eclecticism. Beyond furniture, offerings include candleholders, books, throw pillows, wall art, figurines, totes, stationery, glassware, cutting boards, scarves, welcome mats, and plenty more. Maybe J.Plum will wind up in five categories next year.

PET-SUPPLY STORE

Loyal Biscuit Co.
Various locations

FINALISTS

Two Salty Dogs Pet Outfitters
Boothbay Harbor

Ames True Value Hardware & Supply
Wiscasset

The Animal House
Brunswick, Damariscotta, Westbrook

Pet Pantry
Freeport

BARGAIN STORE

Renys
Various locations

FINALISTS

Marden’s
Various locations

Miles in Motion Thrift Shop
Damariscotta

St. Andrews Thrift Shop
Boothbay Harbor

The Butterfly Barn
Union

Seacraft Vintage, in Kennebunk, Maine

Inside one of Seacraft’s two small spaces. Photo by courtesy of Seacraft

SPOTLIGHT

Jackie Greaney and Paul Havel started collecting nautical-themed odds and ends to deck out their home. Then, they just kept on going. So, four years ago, they decided to open a vintage shop stocked with model boats, oars, nautical flags, lobster buoys, so on and so forth. The inventory is always changing, and their two snug, adjacent spaces in Kennebunk’s Lower Village are always chock-full of curiosities. Still, a pleasing sense of orderliness — a sort of fastidiously uncluttered clutter — somehow prevails. Wes Anderson fans should approve. One senses in Greaney and Havel’s retail sensibilities the influence of their other occupation: running a marketing studio that produces stop-motion animation — bright, cheery, and quirky — for clients ranging from L.L.Bean to Alaska Airlines to Allagash Brewing.

GIFT SHOP

The Grasshopper Shop
Belfast, Rockland

FINALISTS

GooeyGump Designs
Portland

J.Plum Home
Lisbon Falls

The Rusticators Emporium
Hallowell

Pistil & Page
Gardiner

ANTIQUE/VINTAGE SHOP

The Rusticators Emporium
Hallowell

FINALISTS

Miles in Motion Thrift Shop
Damariscotta

J.Plum Home
Lisbon Falls

Talking Threads Market
Oqunquit

Seacraft
Kennebunk

SHOE STORE

Lamey Wellehan Shoes
Various locations

FINALISTS

Colburn Shoe Store
Belfast

Log Cabin Shoes
Boothbay Harbor

Selby Shoes Etc
South Portland

Curtis Family Shoe Store
Ellsworth

Grump & Sunshine owner Cassidy James Taylor

SPOTLIGHT

Belfast is surely home to a disproportionate tally of bibliophiles. Within a few downtown blocks, local literati can browse the public library’s amply stocked shelves, the wide- ranging selection at Left Bank Books (also a finalist on this list), and the used and rare volumes at Craig Olson Books. It wouldn’t have been unreasonable, in the little city of 7,000 people, to figure the market was saturated. Then, last year, Cassidy James Taylor opened Grump & Sunshine — and brought something different to the table. If, upon first stepping inside the bright and charming shop, you didn’t realize its name references the romance genre’s timeless opposites-attract formula, Taylor’s niche focus would become clear enough after a quick glance at titles: As Long as You Love Me, A Million Kisses in Your Lifetime, Bonds of Cupidity. Some of the novels are cozy happily-ever-afters, while others have considerably more, shall we say, zing. All together, they add up to a new chapter in Belfast’s long-running romance with books.

HEALTH & WELLNESS

The wood- fired sauna at Nurture Through Nature in Denmark, Maine

The wood-fired sauna at Nurture Through Nature. Photo by Corey Fitzgerald

SPOTLIGHT

NAIL SALON

Mainely Nails
Damariscotta

FINALISTS

Mia Bella Salon
Rockland

Serenity Nails Lounge
Brunswick

Art Nails
Lewiston

Cozy Nails & Spa
Yarmouth

HAIR SALON/BARBER

Mia Bella Salon
Rockland

FINALISTS

The Hair Lab
Gardiner

Salty Waves Salon
Rockland

Mechanic Street Barbershop
Camden

River’s Edge Spa & Salon
Kennebunk

YOGA STUDIO

Ebb and Flow Yoga
Bath

FINALISTS

Crow Point Yoga
Boothbay Harbor

Chill Yoga
Lewiston

The Daily Sweat
Kennebunk

Sundara Yoga
Brunswick

MASSAGE STUDIO

Wicked Good Massage Therapy
Lewiston

FINALISTS

Revelation Massage
Lewiston, Manchester

Camden Maine Massage Therapy
Camden

Deeply Rooted Massage & Wellness
Kennebunk

*Corrections: Finalist Destination Health Inn & Spa, in Bar Harbor, has closed. In the print issue, we listed Vital Healing, in Rockland, as a finalist. The business owner has clarified that it does not offer massage services, only bodywork; an LMT uses the space part-time to provide massage services.

GYM/FITNESS CENTER

Central Lincoln County YMCA
Damariscotta

FINALISTS

Lawrence Family Fitness Center
Blue Hill

CrossFit Breakwater
Ellsworth

The Daily Sweat
Kennebunk

Shelby Trained
Yarmouth

TRAVEL & PLAY

MARINA

Boothbay Harbor Marina
Boothbay Harbor

FINALISTS

Carousel Marina
Boothbay Harbor

Lyman-Morse
Camden

Journey’s End Marina
Rockland

York Harbor Marine
York

BOAT CRUISE/EXCURSION

Hardy Boat Cruises
New Harbor

FINALISTS

Balmy Days Cruises
Boothbay Harbor

A Morning in Maine
Rockland

Schooner Olad & Cutter Owl
Camden

Schooner Surprise
Camden

GOLF COURSE

Samoset Resort
Rockport

FINALISTS

Boothbay Harbor Country Club
Boothbay

Sugarloaf Golf Club
Carrabassett Valley

Rockland Golf Club
Rockland

Wawenock Golf Club
Walpole

Spruce Point Inn's pool and dock.

Spruce Point Inn’s pool and dock. Photo by courtesy of Spruce Point Inn

SPOTLIGHT

Boothbay Harbor Resorts

SKI MOUNTAIN

Saddleback
Rangeley

FINALISTS

Sugarloaf
Carrabassett Valley

Camden Snow Bowl
Camden

Sunday River
Newry

Pleasant Mountain
Bridgton

B&B/INN

The Craignair Inn by the Sea
Spruce Head

FINALISTS

Topside Inn
Boothbay Harbor

Blue Harbor House Inn
Camden

The Saltair Inn
Bar Harbor

Brewster House Bed & Breakfast
Freeport

HOTEL/RESORT

Samoset Resort
Rockport

FINALISTS

Cliff House Maine
Cape Neddick

Spruce Point Inn
Boothbay Harbor

Boothbay Harbor Oceanside Golf Resort
Boothbay Harbor

Linekin Bay Resort
Boothbay Harbor

ARTS & CULTURE

SPOTLIGHT

SPOTLIGHT

Worthy exhibitions abound right now, from Jeremy Frey’s mind-bogglingly complex Wabanaki basketry at the Portland Museum of Art to Jamie Wyeth’s distinctively dark style at the Farnsworth Art Museum to the Maine Maritime Museum’s highly original exploration of the maritime soundscape. Flying a bit under the radar is an excellent show at the Colby College Museum of Art: Eastman Johnson and Maine. Johnson grew upin Fryeburg and Augusta and became a 19th-century master. He was skilled at portraiture (his subjects included two U.S. presidents), but portrayals of everyday life were his strongest work, and he often looked homeward for inspiration. Almost unbelievably, Colby’s show is the first solo exhibition of his work mounted in Maine.

A Boy in the Maine Woods. c. 1868, oil on board, 12 x 201⁄8 inches. Farnsworth Art Museum, Rockland, Maine. Bequest of Mrs. Elizabeth B. Noyce 97.3.23.

PRIVATE SCHOOL, SECONDARY

Lincoln Academy
Newcastle

FINALISTS

Thornton Academy
Saco

Cheverus High School
Portland

Hebron Academy
Hebron

Saint Dominic Academy
Auburn

PRIVATE SCHOOL, ELEMENTARY

Center for Teaching and Learning
Edgecomb

FINALISTS

Saint Dominic Academy
Auburn

St. Brigid School
Portland

The Riley School
Rockport

The Bay School
Blue Hill

FOOD & DRINK

LOBSTER ROLL

Red’s Eats
Wiscasset

FINALISTS

McLoons Lobster Shack
South Thomaston

The Lobster Haul
Damariscotta

Bite into Maine
Cape Elizabeth, Portland, Scarborough

LDI Lobster
Little Deer Isle

LOBSTER SHACK

Red’s Eats
Wiscasset

FINALISTS

McLoons Lobster Shack
South Thomaston

Five Islands Lobster Co.
Georgetown

The Lobster Shack at Two Lights
Cape Elizabeth

LDI Lobster
Little Deer Isle

ICE-CREAM MAKER

Gifford’s Ice Cream
Various locations

FINALISTS

Fielder’s Choice Ice Cream
Various locations

Round Top Ice Cream
Damariscotta

Dorman’s Dairy Dream
Thomaston

Blanchard’s Creamery
Edgecomb

LDI Lobster owner Anneliese Riggall

LDI Lobster owner Anneliese Riggall. Photo by Peter Frank Edwards

SPOTLIGHT

If the meal gracing this issue’s cover whets your appetite, you’ll want to head for Little Deer Isle, which connects the Blue Hill Peninsula to the larger Deer Isle. Drivers used to breeze right through the in-between island, but since 2018, there’s been a good reason to stop: LDI Lobster. A relative newcomer among Maine seafood shacks, LDI looks like it’s been sitting for ages along placid Eggemoggin Reach, where sailboats glide beneath the Deer Isle Bridge. A finalist in both the lobster shack and roll categories, its roll is a best-of-both-worlds delight: meat tossed lightly in mayo and drizzled with butter. And quality work runs in the family. Owner Anneliese Riggall’s brother, Gavin, saw his architecture firm, North Sky Seven, land as a finalist for best architect this year.

FOOD TRUCK

Taco the Town
Brunswick

FINALISTS

The Zack Shack
Thomaston

Portable Pie Place
Searsport

Mow’s Munchies
Raymond

Black Salt
Portland

BAR

King Eider’s Pub
Damariscotta

FINALISTS

The Abbey
Brunswick

Table Bar
Gardiner

Lucky Betty’s
Camden

Sonder & Dram
Lewiston

SEAFOOD MARKET

Harbor Fish Market
Portland, Scarborough

FINALISTS

Delano Seafood Market
Waldoboro

Jess’s Market
Rockland

Pinkham’s Gourmet Market
Boothbay Harbor

Graffam Bros.
Rockport

BREAKFAST/ BRUNCH SPOT

Home Kitchen Café & Bakery
Rockland

FINALISTS

Bintliff’s Corner Brew
Gardiner

Deb’s Bristol Diner
Bristol

Peace Love & Waffles
Dover-Foxcroft

Barn Door Breakfast
Damariscotta

WINERY

Cellardoor Winery
Lincolnville, Portland

FINALISTS

Sweetgrass Winery & Distillery
Union, Portland

WillowsAwake Winery
Leeds

Winterport Winery
Winterport

Oyster River Winegrowers
Warren

SPOTLIGHT

The venerable King Eider’s Pub has won best bar five years running, and the last time it didn’t win, in 2019, there wasn’t even a category for best bar. Rather, bars were split into distinct categories for beer bars and cocktails bars back then. That Eider’s streak would start once those specialized designations got the ax makes plenty of sense. It’s an unspecialized sort of place, in the best possible way. Everything is good. Some things — the whiskey list comes to mind — are very good. And the atmosphere is darn near unbeatable, as regulars consistently fill the space — wood-beamed ceilings, exposed brick walls, and a general across-the-pond vibe — with conviviality. Two years ago, new owners took over, and though they’ve left their mark on the menu, they didn’t shake things up too much. Best to stick with a winning formula.

COFFEE ROASTER

Coffee By Design
Portland

FINALISTS

Carrabassett Coffee Company
Kingfield

Rock City Coffee Roasters
Rockport

44 North Coffee
Deer Isle, Stonington

Coffee On The Porch
Rockport

BURGER

Owls Head General Store
Owls Head

FINALISTS

King Eider’s Pub
Damariscotta

Newcastle Publick House
Newcastle

Blazes Burgers
Westbrook

Mow’s Munchies
Raymond

Allagash Brewing Company
Portland

FINALISTS

Maine Beer Company
Freeport

Oxbow Brewing Company
Newcastle, Oxford, Portland

Bissell Brother Brewing Co.
Milo, Portland

Odd Alewives Farm Brewery
Waldoboro

HARD-CIDER MAKER

Ricker Hill Mainiac Hard Cider
Auburn, Greene, Turner

FINALISTS

Sea Hag Cider Co.
Rockport

Freedom’s Edge Cider
Albion, Portland

Absolem Cider Company
Winthrop

Winterport Winery
Winterport

a flight of year-round and seasonal ciders from Freedom's Edge Cider

Freedom’s Edge makes year-round and seasonal ciders. Photo by Dave Waddell

SPOTLIGHT

Cider hasn’t undergone a craft-beer type of boom, but between dedicated cideries plus breweries and wineries that produce at least some cider, Maine is home to a solid tally of cider makers — two dozen, at least. Most cider production plays out on a small scale (in part, scaling up requires more apples, and apple trees can mature slowly). In just five years, though, Freedom’s Edge has become the most ubiquitous Maine cider around. It has more than 1,500 trees in its Albion orchard and, crucially, brings in a steady stream of apples from elsewhere. So while the ciders might not be as grounded in terroir as some, they’re well-balanced, consistent, and — no minor feat — easy to find, including at Freedom’s Edge tasting rooms in Albion and Portland. The latter just opened earlier this year.

NEW RESTAURANT

Bred in the Bone
Damariscotta

FINALISTS

Oak & Ember
Buxton

Dos Gatos Gastropub
Belfast

Bon Vivant
Lewiston

*New Restaurant finalist Thistle & Grouse announced its closure on September 27, 2024, via Facebook.

CHOCOLATIER

Wilbur’s of Maine
Brunswick, Freeport

FINALISTS

Bixby Chocolate
Rockland

Haven’s Candy Store
Westbrook, Portland

Ragged Coast Chocolates
Westbrook

Len Libby
Scarborough

APPLE ORCHARD

Ricker Hill Orchard
Turner

FINALISTS

Hope Orchards
Hope

Biscay Orchards
Damariscotta

Rocky Ridge Orchard
Bowdoin

Wallingford’s Orchard
Auburn

CANDY SHOP

Wilbur’s of Maine
Freeport, Brunswick

FINALISTS

Scrummy Afters Candy Shoppe
Gardiner

Granite Hall Store
Round Pond

Orne’s Candy Store
Boothbay Harbor

*Candy Shop finalist Uncle Willy’s Candy Shoppe closed in July 2024.

DINER

Moody’s Diner
Waldoboro

FINALISTS

A1 Diner
Gardiner

Becky’s Diner
Portland

Deb’s Bristol Diner
Bristol

Palace Diner
Biddeford

DONUT SHOP

Holy Donut
Various locations

FINALISTS

Frosty’s Donuts
Brunswick

Ruckus Donuts
Rockland

Old Time Donuts
Damariscotta

The Only Doughnut
Belfast

SPOTLIGHT

Seeing the Bissell Brothers outpost in the small Piscataquis County town of Milo atop our taproom list is bittersweet. Sweet because the location began as a passion project for the Portland-based brewery’s founders, Peter and Noah Bissell, Milo natives looking to do right by their hometown, and also because of the sleek renovation of the former snowmobile shop, the lovely beer garden, the kitchen led by a James Beard Awards “emerging chef” candidate, and the ready supply of some of Maine’s best beer. Bitter — incredibly so — because the space will close by summer’s end. The brothers said it was subsidized by the rest of their operations over its six years, and against inflated costs, declining beer drinking, and a saturated market, they can’t swing it anymore. A big loss for the beer scene, and even bigger for the community.

COFFEE SHOP

Rock City Cafe
Rockland

FINALISTS

Bintliff’s Corner Brew
Gardiner

Greenville Grinds Coffee Shoppe
Greenville

Woodsong Market
Boothbay Harbor

Blue Jay Coffee
Lewiston

FOOD CO-OP

Rising Tide Co-Op
Damariscotta

FINALISTS

Belfast Community Co-Op
Belfast

Blue Hill Co-Op
Blue Hill

Portland Food Co-Op
Portland

Good Tern Co-Op
Rockland

Pat’s Pizza
Various locations

FINALISTS

Cushnoc Brewing Co.
Augusta

Oysterhead Pizza
Damariscotta

Tinder Hearth
Brooksville

Nomad Pizza
Brunswick

Bissell Brothers Three Rivers
Milo

FINALISTS

Mast Landing Brewing Co.
Freeport, South Portland, Westbrook

Odd Alewives Farm Brewery
Waldoboro

Footbridge Brewery
Boothbay Harbor

Winterport Winery / Penobscot Bay Brewery
Winterport

SPOTLIGHT

When torrential rain sent the Kennebec River surging over its banks last December, many homes and businesses in riverfront communities were damaged, Bintliff’s Corner Brew among them. The café — a bustling standby for pastries, cappuccinos, and all-day brunch in Gardiner — lost ovens, mixers, coolers, and pretty much anything else that had been set up or stored in the basement. Reopening took more than two months, but as soon as Bintliff’s was back, the atmosphere was as warm and cozy as ever. Maximalist décor — potted plants all around, dried flowers dangling from the ceiling, and plenty else to catch the eye — helps to reinforce that feeling. So do the equally maximalist portions of standout dishes like bananas-Foster French toast and asparagus-and- prosciutto eggs Benedict.

Roger Bintliff, the namesake owner of Bintliff’s Corner Brew.

Roger Bintliff, the namesake owner of Bintliff’s Corner Brew. Photo by Hannah Hoggatt

Down East magazine, February 2025

Get all of our latest stories delivered straight to your mailbox every month. Subscribe to Down East magazine.