Do Maine’s Newspapers Have a Future?


Cloudy crystal ball: On May 7 at 10 a.m., the Maine Press Association, the Maine State Chamber of Commerce, and Vox Global (a Washington-based public relations firm with an office in Portland) will sponsor a forum called “The Future of Maine’s Newspapers” at the Holiday Inn By The Bay in Portland.

The panelists:

Tony Ronzio, new media director for the Sun Media Group (the Lewiston Sun Journal and its chain of weeklies).

Tom Bell, a reporter at the Portland Press Herald and president of the Portland Newspaper Guild.

Todd Benoit, director of news and new media at the Bangor Daily News.

Terry Carlisle, vice president and general manager of the Ellsworth American.

Bill Kuykendall, journalism professor at the University of Maine.

Coddling Collins: If you get all your news from the Bangor Daily News, you could be excused for thinking U.S. Senator Susan Collins is the hero who may have saved the U.S. Postal Service distribution center in Hampden. According to the BDN’s April 26 account by staff writer Andrew Neff, the Senate approved “Collins’ bill” to preserve many rural facilities by a sizable margin. Collins is said to have “authored the bill,” along with several other senators mentioned in passing. Nothing in Neff’s story explains why anyone would want to shut the Hampden facility down, eliminating 180 jobs. Opponents are mentioned only obliquely.

For a more objective view of the matter, check out the Associated Press coverage, which makes no mention of Collins and devotes considerable space to the serious problems the postal service still faces, problems the bill Collins is said to have authored doesn’t address. Reading this piece raises the question of whether Maine’s junior senator put parochialism ahead of sound policy, an issue the Bangor paper seems inclined to ignore.

Not paying attention to LePage: The Bangor Daily missed out on one of the top stories of last week, even though it had a reporter at the event. Staff writer Alex Barber covered Governor Paul LePage’s capital-for-a-day event in Newport on April 26, but made no mention of the governor calling state employees “corrupt.” 

That comment, reported in the Portland Press Herald and elsewhere, produced a firestorm of criticism, a clarification or two from the LePage administration and some frantic catch-up work by the Bangor paper, which had to cite “press accounts” to explain what all the fuss was about.

Since LePage said little else that was newsworthy at the event, it’s difficult to figure how Barber could have let the “corrupt” comment slip by.

Unless he nodded off.

Al Diamon can be emailed at aldiamon@herniahill.net.

The views expressed on this Web site are those of the authors alone and do not necessarily represent the views of Down East Enterprise or its employees.

Future of newspapers

No matter what the future of newspapers, the panel's makeup shows one thing won't change: in an industry, daily newspapers, in which Poynter says only 33 percent of employees are women, a panel that's 80 percent male will discuss our future.

Industry Experts Indeed

Al, I laughed out loud when I looked at the roster of EXPERTS for the Vox Global event, which is billed as "The Intersection of Business & Media."
Three "new media" gadflies, a union rep, the GM of a weekly once owned by a famous journalist, all sitting on a panel moderated by a PR guy who has never worked in the newspaper business. Classic.
A discussion of the future of Maine newspapers without someone named Sussman, Warren, or Costello on the panel is a non starter.
If Vox had gotten Sussman to talk on the record about how his "loaves and fishes" $3.3 million stake is revitalizing Maine Today Media they might have gotten a crowd. Instead, crickets.
_Munjoy

Future?

With that panel of proven losers? No way.
Your post is like an unpaid ad, Al. Why not talk about how the miserable track record of some of these "experts" has put Maine newspapers in their current sad state, with no business plan, tons of ethical conflicts and political coverage that's bordered on malpractice? To extol them as experts is absurd.
Don't go to this forum, read Clay Shirky, John Paton and others who haven't dug their fingernails in against the market's wish for interactive, 24/7 digital-first news sources.
How long till the next hedge fund bailout at MTM? What really happened at Village Soup? Let us hear it form some of these "experts."