LePage's "Beards" Remark Goes International


lepage_bpa.jpg

In what has become a recurring theme for Maine Governor Paul LePage, a flippant remark has once again earned him days of negative press coverage.

LePage's latest controversial comment, made to reporters last week, is that "there's not been any science identified that there's a problem" with endocrine disrupting chemical bisphenol-A, and that "the only thing that I've heard is if you take a plastic bottle, put it in the microwave and then heat it up it gives off a chemical that's similar to estrogen. And so the worst case is some women might have little beards."

From the initial report in the Bangor Daily News yesterday, the story has spread quickly, and was featured this morning in newspapers as far afield as the Los Angeles Times and the Daily Mail in the UK. Popular science, environmental, and political blogs have also picked up the story.

Susan Sharon at MPBN has perhaps the most comprehensive coverage, with reaction from environmental groups, the Maine Women's Lobby and the Maine toxicologist tasked by the state with studying the chemical.

"In the last ten years or so there have been more than a hundred papers, working with animals documenting effects at much lower levels and in different kinds of systems and in different kinds of receptors," Dr. Deborah Rice is quoted as saying. "So in my mind, it's no longer a controversy whether bisphenol A in animals produces adverse effects at the same levels that humans are exposed to."

Rice notes that research has linked BPA to cancer, sexual dysfunction and heart disease in humans and could have the most damaging effects on developing fetuses and children.

Beard growing is not one of the chemical's known effects.

LePage spokesperson Dan Demeritt has defended the statement as a "casual joke" that has been blown out of proportion.

Not only is this joke another hit to LePage's personal credibility and stature as governor, but it's just about the most damaging thing he could have said in regards to his position on this controversial issue.

From a communications point of view, a joke about women with beards, even an inaccurate one, brings home the dangerous and scary effects of a toxic chemical's effects on our bodies' basic processes in a way that lab reports and scientific papers never could. The image in people's minds as they consider LePage's plan to allow BPA into baby bottles and sippy-cups will now be a woman with a beard.

The first part of LePage's statement is troubling as well. He didn't just say that he disagrees with or finds flaws with the science showing real and dangerous health effects of BPA, he claims that it doesn't exist.

This means that he hasn't looked into the science himself and that his advisers, some of whom have been lobbyists for the chemical industry and other opponents of BPA regulation, are obviously providing him a very narrow view of the issue.

LePage's full remarks:

 

The views expressed on this Web site are those of the authors alone and do not necessarily represent the views of Down East Enterprise or its employees.

If anyone thinks that the

If anyone thinks that the repeal of a ban on a harmful chemical that has been linked to cancer is a waste of time (as far as media coverage), than that person is sad. That's not even the sad part. The sad part is that the Governor has confused accelerated estrogen effects with accelerated testosterone effects. Yet we're supposed to believe him when it comes to scientific facts (such as "The worst thing that will happen..."). Sad.

BPA

It is sad that media has so little to do that it's focus is on what was clearly an attempt at levity by Gov. Lepage. It should be paying a little more attention to the devastating effects on this country and state that our current president's policies are causing. Local and national media are obviously slanted to the far left which is far more alarming to me than a comment about women growing beards. We should be spending time getting rid of useless government expense like the Natural Resource Council and other worthless government departments. Political correctness and liberalism will be the death of us all.

trotnixon's picture

Way to miss the point...

the issue is not whether the comment was a joke or not, but as Tipping points out, a pattern is emerging where this governor is willing to ignorantly dismiss years of scientific evidence based on some anecdote told to him by some chemical industry lobbyist over lunch without so much as a question about the validity of what he was told.

I'm glad we have reporters that are keeping watch on what's happening in Augusta. It's a sign of a healthy democracy.

You want Maine reporters to turn their attention away from Maine and focus it on Washington, D.C.? Why? Do you honestly believe the President of the United-freaking States is a story that is lacking in coverage?

Are you saying there's TOO MUCH local coverage of the issues affecting people in Maine?

I'm wasting my time aren't I?

Removing toxins from our homes

Would love to know Mr LePage's qualifications to be interpreting scientific data and making decisions on our behalf.... Seems like he needs some good advice and not from whoever he is currently talking with.

Meanwhile today in Vermont they are discussing the removal of all toxins from homes and schools

http://www.vpirg.org/node/376
http://www.good-chemistry.org/?p=2175

Time to catch up Governor.