Woodard’s Non-Disclosure, Part Two


Envision this: I took plenty of flack from fans of Colin Woodard’s investigative reporting for my recent posting criticizing him for not disclosing in his two-part biography of Republican Gov. Paul LePage in the Portland Phoenix that his wife is involved with OneMaine, a political action committee started by Eliot Cutler. LePage narrowly defeated independent Cutler in the 2010 gubernatorial race and is widely expected to face a rematch in 2014.

Most of those who didn’t agree with my call for full disclosure said the Woodard-Cutler connection was too tenuous to represent a real conflict of interest or even the perception of one. They claimed the controversy I was attempting to raise distracted from the excellent work Woodard did in digging into LePage’s background.

I agree with half of that. The LePage bio was well done and shed considerable light on the origin of the governor’s political views. But with the arrival of the second installment, Republicans and other anti-Cutler types have been sending me more evidence that my call for additional disclosure wasn’t unreasonable.

Late in part two of the LePage piece, Woodard quotes Alan Caron, who served on the governor-elect’s transition team, making disparaging remarks about that process. Caron argued that LePage’s Tea Party allies scared away many moderates from seeking jobs in the new administration, saying “good people didn’t apply and those that did were rejected.” He also criticized LePage for demanding loyalty from his appointees. “Anyone who wants loyalty above all else is not secure enough or confident enough to build a strong team of good leaders,” Caron said.

Here’s what Woodard neglected to mention.

He’s been hired by Caron, in his capacity as head of the think tank Envision Maine, to co-author a report on improving Maine’s economy that’s scheduled to be released in May. In addition, Eliot Cutler is listed in a recent fund-raising appeal as being a member of Envision Maine’s advisory council, a group that includes a number of prominent centrist politicians including former Gov. Angus King and potential MaineToday Media owner Chris Harte.

Judging from my correspondence, I might be the only non-Republican in the state who cares about these undisclosed connections of Woodard’s. But I do, and I think you should, too.

(For the record, my weekly political column runs in the Phoenix.)

Speaking of Eliot Cutler: Has there ever been a puffier piece on a politician than the one WCSH-TV’s Bill Green did recently on Cutler? Green feeds the likely candidate softballs for more than six minutes, never raising a question about his time in China (during which he became extremely wealthy) or the veracity of many of the negative claims raised by “The Cutler Files” website.

This looks like nothing less than a long campaign commercial airing more than two and a half years before the election.

Al Diamon can be emailed at aldiamon@herniahill.net.

The views expressed on this Web site are those of the authors alone and do not necessarily represent the views of Down East Enterprise or its employees.

This is really a nice and

This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it
grezed

Great Information sharing ..

Great Information sharing .. I am very happy to read this article .. thanks for giving us go through info.Fantastic nice. I appreciate this post.
play zuma

Woodard's apologists are pathetic

To suggest that prostituting yourself out as a "co-author" for an organization with an ideological axe to grind and not disclosing it is okay because that's just how it is in a small state like Maine is a bitter indictment of the incestuous nature of so-called "advocacy journalism" in which the ends always justify the means. Al, don't let Woodward's apologists dissuade you from this path of inquiry; some journalists (still) have integrity.

Maine is small

Everyone has connections to someone or some org in Maine. It's just too damn small a state to not be affiliated with someone. For a journalist to list, or disclose, every affiliation is a distraction for this reader. Just give me the story and facts. Everyone has a bias, a background, a personal story, and I expect that in anyone making a point, shedding light on a dark spot, or simply telling a story. Sorry, Al, your fuss over Colin's non-disclosure comes across as small as our state.

Non Republican?

I thought you were buddies with Dan Billings? I'm an Independent who finds the lack of disclosure worthy of a note.

Glenn Greenwald recently gave Krugman a drubbing on same issue.

http://www.salon.com/2010/01/16/krugman_5/singleton/

Not sure how believable The New York Times is after Iraq war debacle but the Public Editor, Clark Hoyt on a series of non-disclosures:

"they all share the common element of having run afoul of the principle that “readers are entitled to disclosure so they can decide if there is a conflict that would affect the credibility of the information.”"

Quasimodo

Disclosure: Leech of my mother and sole member of "Citizens for wood burning in efficient stoves & de-electrification"